Donnerstag, 21. November 2013

New anti-government protest in Bangkok - a small chronicle


Protest camp of the "Students´ and People´s Network for Thailand Reform" at Makkawan bridge.



Zur deutschen Version


Worachai Hema
The latest series of anti-government-protests started in early August, when Pheu Thai MP Worachai Hema proposed the first version of an amnesty bill to the parliament (http://yanawa.blogspot.com/2013/08/thailands-gossip-factory-is-working.html).
In his proposal only protesters (pro- and anti-government supporters alike as well as red- and yellow shirts) should be granted amnesty (beginning from 2006 until 2010). Protest leaders, responsible politicians, ousted prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra, high ranking military officers and other authorities involved in violent protests, airport occupations, arsoning of buildings and the brutal crackdowns in April and Mai 2010 had been excluded from the amnesty.
The public response against this proposal was only lukewarm. The first protest of the PEFOT-movement (People's Force for Democracy to Overthrow Thaksinism) at Lumpini park was joined by 3,500 - 5,000 protesters only. The following days and weeks the support decreased more and more, sometimes only a few hundred people joined their rallies.


First PEFOT protest on 04.08.2013 at Lumpini park.



PEFOT rally site at Lumpini park on August 7th.


















































Also the protest rally of the Democrat Party and their announced march on parliament on 7th August 2013 was a complete failure. Just some 2,500 protesters joined the protest march that was stopped by police forces far off the parliament building.

Protest march of Democrat Party supporters on August 7th.




























The whole situation changed dramatically in October 2013 just before the second and third reading of the proposed amnesty bill. On the quiet the House Committee varied the terms of the first version of the amnesty bill (as proposed by MP Worachai Hema) which already passed the first reading and added the suggestions of MP Prayuth Siripanich. Now all persons, which had been excluded in the first draft, were now included in a general amnesty, also Thaksin Shinawatra. This new version was backdated to 2004. But again, in this revised draft the 112 prisoners /political prisoners were excluded from the blanket amnesty!
(http://yanawa.blogspot.com/2013/11/the-blanket-amnesty-bill-final-version.html)

On 1st November, after the second and third reading in a 19 hour parliamentary session, nearly all of the remaining MP's voted in favour of the amended version of the general amnesty (all MP's of the oppsition parties left the hall before the final voting or abstained from polling).

The way the bill was passed and the amendments were implemented sparked a wave of anger across ALL political camps! Four Pheu Thai MP's abstained from voting, and many non-parliamentarian groups voiced their discontent about a possible return of  Thaksin Shinawatra. Other groups critisized the unconstitutional process of the voting,and the anti-government groups intensified their protests, and many people were frustrated and enraged, that Thaksin should escape unpunished.
Interestingly, all those human rights violations during the protests and crackdowns in 2010 were seen as irrelevant for most of these anti-amnesty respectively anti-government protesters.

But this time the wave of protest was joined by many relatives of the injured or killed protesters and soldiers. Also several red shirt groups staged anti-amnesty-bill protests.

According to "The Nation" newspaper, Sombat Boon-ngamanong, organizer of the Red Sunday group explained: "We are here to show that our principles have not changed. We are against amnesty for state killers. We don't forget what happened at Ratchaprasong. Yingluck should apologise, especially to the redshirts who elected her. We want an amnesty for lese majeste political prisoners." He also demanded that Abhisit Vejjajiva and Yingluck Shinawatra - the past and present prime ministers - should also come forward to apologise to the people, especially the leader who presided over the fatal crackdown in 2010.

"We disagree with the amnesty but we don’t want to see this government fall because of growing pressure from the opposition," said Thawon Songprasom, 50.
(http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/Red-shirts-send-mixed-messages-30219166.html)

Dr. Weng (with microphone), Sombat (with black hat) and Jatuporn at the Redshirt protest at Ratchaprasong on 10 November.

Katthiyaa Sawasdipol, daughter of assassinated Major-General Katthiya Sawasdipol aka "Seh Daeng".



Phayao Akkhahad, mother of a paramedic killed during 2010 crackdowns, called for Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra to issue an apology for have "betrayed the people" by pushing for a blanket amnesty that would cover those responsible for the crackdowns.


"Supporters of amnesty acted like thieves calling for help to shield the government after being caught trying to steal from the people," she said. Phayao urged the red shirts not fall prey to protect the government, which had been insensitive to the people's feelings.

(http://www.nationmultimedia.com/index.php)



Mr Worachet (the complete comment of the Nitirat Group at  http://prachatai.com/english/node/3732) said the new version of the bill could be unconstitutional because it was not in line with the version approved by the House in the first reading in August. He said the ruling party could still save face by voting down the bill in the second reading, which began yesterday, and set up a "committee of the whole House" to re-examine the Worachai bill section by section. He also asked why the amnesty bill does not cover those charged under the Criminal Code's Section 112 known as the lese majeste law, since such a condition contradicted the principle of people's liberty.


"The amnesty is supposed to deal with types of offences that are connected to the political conflicts since the coup. So how do the lawmakers know that charges brought under Section 112 were not also tied to the conflict?" he said.
(http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/politics/377465/amnesty-dishonest-nitirat-group-claims)



Obviously, some very "influential Pro-Thaksin supporters" were very angered by the anti-anmnesty protest of some redshirt leaders. Without warning the shows of Sombat, Jatuporn, Thida and Nattawut were axed by the redshirt tv-station ASIA UPDATE.
So much for freedom of speech and democracy!

- Asia Update online television station had no justification in removing programmes hosted by four red leaders, Pheu Thai MP Weng Tojirakarn said on Monday.
Should the station want to promote the amnesty bill, it then ought to introduce the views of amnesty proponents instead of blocking the dissenting voices, he said.
The cancelled programmes involved red leader Jatuporn Promphan, Deputy Commerce Minister Nattawut Saikua, Red Sunday leader Sombat Boonngamanong and Weng's wife Thida Thavornseth.
The station, run by pro-Thaksin allies, were seen as close to the red shirts -

(http://www.nationmultimedia.com/breakingnews/Asia-Update-TV-removes-red-programmes-30218672.html)

...Pheu Thai list MP and United Front for Democracy against Dictatorship (UDD) core member Went Tojirakarn on Monday asked AsiaUpdate, the satellite TV station for the red-shirts, why it has removed shows hosted by four leading red-shirt figures from its programming schedule. The four are Sombat Boonngamanong, leader of the Red Sunday Group, Tida Thawornseth, the UDD chair, Jatuporn Prompan, a UDD core member, and Deputy Commerce Minister Nattawut Saikuar, also a UDD core member.
They all have voiced opposition to the amnesty bill as revised by the House scrutiny committee to offer a blanket amnesty, which they said would allow those who ordered the crackdowns on red-shirt protesters in 2010, resulting in 92 deaths and hundreds of injuries, to go unpunished.
Mr Weng said he did not understand why the executives of the satellite TV station did this, saying that this showed they did not support democracy, which in principle does not obstruct but is open to the expression of different opinions...




Redshirt protesters chanted "Ti nii mi khun thaai" - people died/were killed here!



























Democrat Party protest:
From November 2nd on,  the Democrat Party started its own permanent protest camp near Samsen train station instead of joining the other protest groups as PEFOT (still at Lumpini park) or the Student's Network (at Urupong intersection). They called for everyone to join their protest to stop the amnesty bill. At this time (around 3rd November) Abhisit Vejjajiva and the Democrat Party declared in public all protests should stay within the limits of the law. Their intention was to stop the amnesty bill only, and not to oust the government. In this point they differed from PEFOT and the Student's Network which main goal was to kick out the government from the beginning.

The former permanent camp of the Student and People's Network at Urupong, 03.11.2013.





03.11.2013, the stage at the Democrat Party camp at Samsen station at 11.30.



On November 2nd, the public feedback was definitively better as on 7th August. In the evening between 8,000 and 10,000 people joined the rally. But this was still less than expected by the leadership of the Democrat Party (DP). Suthep Thaugsuban, former deputy prime minister and protest leader of the Democrats, called on the people to come out in force the next day and join the protest against the amnesty bill from 10.00 AM on at the Samsen protest camp. Maybe it was too hot, too "early" in the morning or it was just the location, anyway, only a few hundred protesters had arrived until noon. It must have been very disappointing for the organizers. Only later in the evening some thousands people gathered at the rally site.


Moving the camps to new locations:
Maybe that's why protest key-leader Suthep and the DP decided to move their rally site to a far more significant location and to occupy the area around Democracy Monument at Rachadamnoen Road on November 4th. This was a clear violation of the ISA (Internal Security Act).
So much for Abhisit's announcement, that the protesters will respect the rule of law and won't get involved in any criminal actions. 
But to use this area is also a provocation to the Redshirts. 26 people (protesters and soldiers alike) got killed at or near the Monument during the first crackdown when Abhisit and Suthep ordered the army to disperse the Redshirt protest on 10th April 2010 (http://yanawa.blogspot.com/2013/04/the-red-shirt-protest-personal-diary.html).

03.11.2013, around 11 o'clock Suthep Thaugsuban arrived at the protest site at Samsen station.

The new rally site of the Democrats at Rachadamnoen.


Also the other two main protest groups moved their rally sites. On November 7th the "Students' and People's Network" moved their camp to Makkawan bridge (near to the United Nations building and close to the Government House). This was one of the main protest sites of the second PITAK Siam protest in 2012 (http://yanawa.blogspot.com/2012/11/pitak-siam-at-makkawan-bridge-day-when.html).

On 27 October the Students' Network was joined by Chamrong Srimuangs's Dhamma Army (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chamlong_Srimuang) and got support from several unions like the Labour Union of Government Pharmaceutical Corporation, the Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand (EGAT), the Worker's Union of the CAT Telecom, The State Enterprise Workers' Relations Confederation of Thailand (SERC), etc.

07 November 2013, several police battalions were stationed at Makkawan bridge.
Barricade made of  concrete blocks at Makkawan bridge.



In front of the stage of the Students' Network opposite the Military Headquarter.

Students' Network supporter at makkawan bridge.


PEFOT (People's Army to Overthrow the Thaksin Regime) moved to Phan Fa Bridge on November 5, another provocation  for the Redshirts. At this location the Redshirts established their first permanent rally site during the anti-government protest in 2010 before they moved to Ratchaprasong. But in general the PEFOT is becoming less important.
(http://yanawa.blogspot.com/2013/03/march-to-may-2010-personal-diary-part-1.html)

11 November 2013, PEFOT supporters at Phan Fa bridge.


Whistle-blowing:
On 4th November a new group joined the anti-government protests: the "Business Club for Democracy" (BCD) led by the businessman Somkiat Homla-or. This group of  wealthy businessmen founded and organised the so-called "Silom Lovers Group" which defended (so they claim) the Silom commercial district against the Redshirts in 2010. Some of their so-called supporters and/or mob attacked and tried to kill people who they thought were Redshirts or Redshirt supporters. 

So-called supporters of the Silom lovers Group attacking a car of a probably Redshirt in 2010.

The BCD called for all office workers, business owners and their employees to join anti-amnesty rallies (called whistle-blowing) around noon during their lunch break at significant commercial centres all over Bangkok. As a sign of protest they all should blow a whistle. The BCD itself was surprised by the large number of protesters that joined their first rally at Sala Daeng station on Silom road on November 4th. Some 8,000 people gathered at the protest site (others claim more than 10,000, but that's defintively exaggerated). Their campaign ended two weeks later when the senate rejected the amnesty-bill on November 11th. 


04.11.2013, rally organized by Business Club for Democracy



After the Senate rejected the Bill:

On November 11th, after a 12 hour meeting, the Senate unanimously rejected the blanket amnesty. This means even those senators close to the government rejected the bill.
On the same day Suthep Thaugsuban, and 8 other party members of the Democrat Party resigned from their jobs as Members of Parliament. (http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/politics/379322)
Suthep declared on the stage at the Democracy Monument that now the time has come to oust the governement!
Ooops, didn't Abhisit Vejjajiva announce just a few days ago that this protest is just about the amnesty bill and that the Democrat Party has no intention at all to oust the government? 
Another promise broken!
Suthep called for three days of civil disobedience and a nation-wide general strike. All employees and workers should stop working from Wednesday 15th to Friday 18th. He also called on schools and universities to cancel all classes for those three days. As another expression of disobedience everyone who supports the protest should raise the Thai national flag at home, carry it with them as head- or wristband or display it on their car. Any kind of civil disobedience that's NOT violating any law would be welcome. Finally he asked the businesses to delay their payment of their corporate taxes. But here he overstepped the mark! He asked the companies to infringe the law! (We remember the announcement of party leader Abhisit: protesters should respect the rule of law! Again, another promise broken!)
But the "Three Days of Disobedience" were a complete failure. I saw no one wearing or rising the national flag apart from the rally sites. I heard about no school or university cancelling their classes (at least not where I live and our district is very conservative and anything but red) and only a very small number of companies followed the call for a general strike.

Here two comments on Suthep's call for civil diobedience:

Narudom Roongsiriwong, an executive director at ECOP, said Suthep's four actions were not reasonable, especially when it came to not paying corporate tax. He said not paying tax was illegal and the three-day strike would only damage the economy. "What he is asking us to do is illegal," he said.

Presit Klong-Nguluerm, chairman of the Thai Electronic Publishing Club, also said not paying tax was illegal and pointed out that the illegal amnesty bill cannot be fought using illegal means. "It is not the right thing to do."
http://www.nationmultimedia.com/politics/Suthep-civil-disobedience-move-bit-unreasonable-30219456.html



Suthep's call for the final battle:

After the desastrous failure of Suthep's call for civil disobidience he is obviously getting more and more desperate. The protest is loosing continously it's momentum since the Senate rejected the bill. Therefor he is warmongering and his speeches are getting more aggressive. On November 17th he declared in front of estimated 20,000 supporters at the Democracy Monument:
...Ex-Democrat MP and anti-government protest leader Suthep Thaugsuban is mobilising people to join a "major battle day" next Sunday at the Democracy Monument.
"This is your last chance to be part of an historic day when Thais free themselves from the Thaksin regime. This is the final opportunity for you to create a better future for our next generations," Mr Suthep told about 20,000 people at a rally on Sunday night. "For those who have not come out, Nov 24 is battle day. It's time to wage a war," he said. "Please come out to join this fight. Next Sunday will be the victory day of the people." He said he expected at least one million people to turn up on that day. Mr Suthep also urged people from the provinces to come to Bangkok. "For those who can't who can't come here, please gather at the provincial hall at your province and wait for a signal from the Ratchadamnoen stage," Mr Suthep said...



The Constitutional Court's decision on the Charter amendment:

This was another attempt by the DP to topple the government. They hoped the Court may dissolve the ruling coalition parties according to Article 68 of the Constitution. More about this topic you can find in this brilliant summary:

The Constitutional Court on 20 November.


























(Text by Saksith Saiyasombut, Siam Voices)
UPDATE (Nov 20, 14.30h): The Constitutional Court ruled that the charter amendments to be unlawful, but did not disband the ruling Pheu Thai Party and their coalition partners. The judges took offense at the many irregularities during the parliamentary process (such as MPs using their absent colleagues voter ID cards to vote on their behalf) and the changes to Article 115.5 of the Constitution (see below). Full story and analysis here.
The current political tensions in Thailand could be prolonged this morning (Wednesday) at 11am as the Constitutional Court yet again decides on the constitutionality of proposed amendments brought forward by the ruling Pheu Thai Party (PT). A rejection could also yet again threaten PT and Prime Minister Yingluck Shinawatra’s grip on power – something that anti-government protesters are counting on.
(http://asiancorrespondent.com/116010/uncharted-amendments-thai-constitutional-court-to-decide-on-govts-fate-yet-again/)



Prof Ukrit Mongkolnavin, speaking at a seminar on on the charter court's role, warned that the ruling may interfere with royal powers because the draft has already been submitted for royal endorsement and it may trigger violence. "The court will interfere with royal powers and may have to be responsible for any deaths that may result from a clash," ...

Prinya Tevanaruemitrkul, a law lecturer at Thammasat University, said yesterday the rejection of the court's powers by government MPs and senators is irrelevant as the amendment is now pending royal endorsement.
http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/local/380698/somsak-reds-fire-up-charter-row


Anti-Government protesters in front of the Constitutional Court.





 
Everybody is waiting now for Suthep starting his "final war" on Sunday. If this fails also, then Bangkok will return hopefully back to normal. The parliament´s final session for this year is on Friday, November 29th and the preparations for the celebrations of the birthday of His Majesty the King on December 5th will go on (which could last between one and several weeks, the duration has still to be announced by the government).  All protest parties already agreed to clear their camps and to stop the protests during the celebrations inside the designated areas for the parades and celebration activities .



Freitag, 15. November 2013

Photo exhibition: Goodbye my Chechnya





On Tuesday, November 12th, there was a very interesting exhibition with photographs of  Diana Markosian's. My images below can provide only a glimpse of the mostly melancholic, sometimes enigmatic atmosphere of many of her photographs. Amongst other things the glas surface of the picture frames was strongly reflecting therefor the quality of my pictures I've taken during the exhibition is everything but perfect. You can discover more great images and artwork of Diana Markosian (and in full quality) on her webpage:



All photos on this page are shown by leave of the artist.
Die Veröffentlichung der Fotos geschieht mit ausdrücklicher Erlaubnis der Künstlerin.

Am Dienstag, den 12. November, war in der Rooftop Gallery eine höchst interessante Ausstellung mit Fotos von Diana Markosian zu sehen. Weil unter anderem das Glas der Bilderrahmen extrem stark reflektierte, können meine Bilder nur annähernd einen Eindruck von dem hintergründigen Witz und der melancholischen Atmosphäre ihrer Arbeiten vermitteln. Weitere großartige Bilder und Arbeiten kann man auf ihrer Webpage (natürlich in bester Qualität) entdecken:





ABOUT THE EXHIBITION:
(original text from the artist)

For young girls in Chechnya the most innocent acts could mean breaking the rules.
In Tschetschenien kann eine unbedachte Handlung von jungen Mädchen bereits einen Gesetzesbruch bedeuten.

A Chechen girl caught smoking is cause for arrest; while rumors of a couple having sex before marriage can result in an honor killing.

Wenn ein Mädchen beim Rauchen erwischt wird kann es dafür verhaftet werden; derweil reichen schon Gerüchte, dass ein Liebespaar vor der Heirat Sex hatte, als Grund für einen Ehrenmord.

The few girls who dare to rebel become targets in the eyes of Chechen authorities.
Die wenigen jungen Frauen, die dagegen rebellieren, geraten ins Visier der tschetschenischen Autoritäten.

After nearly two decades of vicious war and 70 years of Soviet rule, during which religious participation was banned, modern-day Chechnya is going through Islamic revival.
Nach fast zwei Jahrzehnten eines mörderischen Krieges und 70 Jahren unter sowjetischer Herrschaft, in der die Ausübung der Religion verboten war, erlebt das heutige Tschetschenien ein Wiederaufblühen des Islams.

The Chechen government is building mosques in every village, prayer rooms in public schools, and enforcing a stricter Islamic dress code for both men and women.
Die tschetschenische Regierung errichtet in jedem Dorf Moscheen, richtet in öffentlichen Schulen Gebetsräume ein und setzt eine strenge Kleiderordnung  für Männer und Frauen durch.

This photo essay chronicles the lives of young Muslim girls who witnessed the horrors of two wars and are now coming of age in a republic that is rapidly redefining itself as a Muslim state.
Diese Fotoreportage berichtet von dem Leben junger Frauen, welche den Horror zweier Kriege erleben mussten und nun in einer Republik erwachsen werden, die sich immer schneller in einem muslimischen Staat umdefiniert.





The Photographer
(original text from Diana Markosian homepage:)


Diana Markosian is a documentary photographer based in Yangon, Myanmar.

Her reporting has previously taken her from Russia's volatile North Caucasus, to the ancient Silk Road in Tajikistan and overland to the remote Wakhan Corridor in northeastern Afghanistan.

Diana's images have appeared in The New York Times, Le Monde, The Sunday Times, Marie Claire, Foreign Policy,Time.com, World Policy Journal, Human Rights Watch, and Amnesty International, amongst others.

Her work has been recognized by a diverse number of organizations including The Magnum Emerging Photographer Fund, Open Society Institute, the National Press Photographers Association, UNICEF and Reuters. In 2013, Diana was selected to participate in the World Press Photo Joop Swart Masterclass.

She holds a masters from Columbia University's Graduate School of Journalism
























































































































































 

























_____________________________________________________________________________________


Also interesting: I AM BANGKOK - photo exhibition by Lillian Suwanrumpha
                          http://yanawa.blogspot.com/2013/06/i-am-bangkok-photo-exhibition-by.html



THE ROOFTOP GALLERY
In 2012 Farmani gallery established a photo gallery in Phnom Penh, at Le Leela Hotel and the Rooftop gallery in Bangkok, in order to showcase the international work to Asian markets and discover great Asian photographers.

The location:
440/10 Sukhumvit 55 ( Thong Lor) , 4th floor, Bangkok, Thailand 10110
The Gallery is situated between Soi 14 and 16, opposite J-Avenue and the Home Place tower (with an UOB branch on the ground floor). The gallery is located on the rooftop (of course) of a four storey building. Also situated in this building is the DESIGN INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE (having a large signboard on the house front).

Anfahrt:
440/10 Sukhumvit 55 ( Thong Lor) , 4th floor, Bangkok, Thailand 10110
Die Galerie befindet sich in einem vierstöckigen Gebäude zwischen der Soi 14 und 16, indem auch das DESIGN INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTE beheimatet ist (mit großem Namenszug auf der Straßenfassade).



The FARMANI GALLERY
(original text from Farmani Gallery homepage: http://www.farmanigallery.com/)

Hossein Farmani established the Farmani Gallery in 2003 as a contemporary photography gallery space to carry on his passion for discovering, collecting and sharing photo-based artworks. The Farmani Gallery is a perfect complement to Hossein Farmani’s many other photographic endeavors.

In 2008, the sights were set on taking the gallery to New York and it was settled in the emerging artistic neighborhood of D.U.M.B.O., Brooklyn. Continuing the foresight from the gallery space in Los Angeles, Farmani continues to establish its vision in New York. Focusing on an International artistic diversification with programming and artist and making these artworks available for art enthusiast and art collectors.

In 2010 and beyond, Farmani Gallery embraces the changes in the art market and continues the efforts and passion of its owner, Hossein Farmani, to provide insights to emerging tastes and artists, building on cultural cues, and a dedication fine art photography excellence in its artist and for its art patronage.


Freitag, 1. November 2013

The blanket amnesty bill - final version and voting

This morning (Friday, 1 November 2013) we were caught off guard by the ruling coalition rapid second and third reading and final approval of the controversial amnesty bill. The final vote was not expected before 2 November. Instead the coalition MPs rushed in unbelievable speed through the decision-making process. The voting on the amnesty bill was done at 04.25 AM.
Heute morgen (Freitag, den 01.November 2013) wurden wir alle von der Nachricht überrascht, dass die Abgeordneten des Repräsentantenhauses noch in der Nacht vom 31.Oktober auf den 01.November das umstrittene Amnestiegesetz durch die zweite und dritte Lesung gejagt und schließlich verabschiedet hatten. Geplant war die Abstimmung über das Gesetz eigentlich für den 02.November, offensichtlich hatte die Regierung es sehr, sehr eilig, den Gesetzesentwurf zu verabschieden. Die Abstimmung fand um 4.25 Uhr morgens in der Frühe statt!

In the next 60 days the Senators of Thailands Upper House have to decide if they approve or oppose this revised version of the amnesty bill. It is quite possible that the Senators reject the amnesty bill because the constitution of the Seante is different from the parliament. The Upper House (or National Assembly of Thailand) is composed of 150 members, 76 are directly elected from Thailands provinces and 74 appointed by the Senate Selection Committee.
In den nächsten 60 Tagen müssen nun die Senatoren des Oberhauses über die Gesetzesvorlage entscheiden. Es ist durchaus möglich, dass sie das Gesetz ablehnen, da die Zusammensetzung des Senates von der des Repräsentantenhauses abweicht. Das Oberhaus hat 150 Mitglieder, davon werden 76 direkt in den Provinzen gewählt und 74 von der Auswahlkommission des Senates bestimmt.

According to the Nitirat Group the blanket amnesty is unconstitutional because the version of the second and third reading is not in line with the approved first version of the amnesty bill explained Worachet Pakeerut. As mentioned in my post yesterday (http://yanawa.blogspot.com/2013/10/tensions-are-rising-again-in-thailand.html), the first version - proposed by MP Worachai Hema - excluded all leading figures and authorities (Thaksin, Abhisit, Suthep, protest leaders, the army and other authorities) from the amnesty. The new, revised version, proposed by Prayuth Siripanich, now includes all leaders, politicians, the army and authorities involved in political unrest, crackdowns and violence since 2004 (WHY 2004? Tak Bai? Krue Se? ... see Section 3 of the translation at the end of this post).
In den Augen der Nitirat Gruppe ist diese Version der Generalamnestie verfassungswidrig, da die verabschiedete Version der zweiten und dritten Lesung nicht identisch ist mit der Version der ersten Lesung, erklärte Worachet Pakeerut. Wie ich schon in meinem Blog gestern erwähnte (http://yanawa.blogspot.com/2013/10/die-spannungen-in-bangkok-steigen.html), waren in der ersten Version von MP (Member of Parliament) Worachai Hema alle Autoritäten, die Anführer der Proteste, die Armee und die verantwortlichen Politiker von der Amnestie ausgeschlossen. Nach der ersten Lesung wurde der Gesetzesentwurf allerdings nach Vorschlägen des Abgeordneten Prayuth Siripanich vom Hauskomitee überarbeitet und abgeändert. In der neuen Version werden nun auch alle jene amnestiert, die in der ersten Version noch von der Amnestie ausgeschlossen waren, rückwirkend bis 2004 (aber warum jetzt 2004? Damals gab es noch keine politischen Unruhen oder Proteste oder will man die Verantwortlichen an den Massakern von Krue Se und Tak Bai gleich mitamnestieren?).

Abhisit Vejjajiva, leader of the Democrat Party, the largest oppostion party in the House of Representatives, declared on 1 November that the Democrat Party will file a petition to the Constitutional Court for legal interpreation of the amnesty bill. They also regard, as the Nitirat Group, the revision of the bill after the first and before the second and third reading as unconstitional. He asked the Senators to reject the bill.
Abhisit Vejjajiva, Führer der größten Oppositionspartei, der Democrat Party, erklärte am 01.November, dass die Democrat Party beabsichtigt, das Gesetz dem Verfassungsgericht zur Überprüfung vorzulegen. Sie sind ebenfalls wie die Nitirat Gruppe überzeugt, dass der Ablauf des Verfahrens verfassungswidrig war. Abhisit forderte zugleich die  Senatoren auf, die Gesetzesvorlage zurückzuweisen.

A very good analysis by David Streckfuss:
http://www.bangkokpost.com/opinion/opinion/377474/truth-will-be-buried-under-blanket-amnesty




Voting results after the third reading/Abstimmungsergebnis:
Seats total:          500 (Pheu Thai Party 265, Democrat Party 159, Bhumjaithai 34,
Gesamtzahl Abgeordnete:      Chartthaipattana Party 19, Others 23)
Votes cast:          314 (186 MPs walked out under protest before voting or simlpy boycotted
Abgegebene Stimmen:          the voting, 186 Abgeordnete verließen aus Protest den Saal oder boykottierten
                                           die Abstimmung)
Yes/Ja:                310 (Pheu Thai 265, Bhumjaithai 29 or 30?, Chartthaipattana Party 19)
No/Nein:                 0
Abstention:            4 (Khattiya Sawasdipol, Worachai Hema, Dr. Weng Tojirakarn, Nattawut
Enthaltung:                          Saikua - all/alle Pheu Thai Party)


These seven Red Shirt leaders votes for the amnesty bill:
Diese sieben Anführer der Rothemden stimmten für die Gesetzesvorlage:
Korkaew Pikulthong, Cherdchai Tontisirin, Apiwan Wiriyachai, Wiphuthalang Phattanaphumthai, Phayap Punket, Shinawatra Haboonpad and Prasit Chaisisa.

Red-shirt MP Korkaew Pikulthong, however, did vote in support of the bill. He later posted a message on his Facebook account saying he had voted as a Pheu Thai MP and not as a red-shirt co-leader.
Korkaew Pikulthong, einer der Rothemdenanführer und Pheu Thai MP, stimmte für das Amnestiegesetz. Später postete er eine Nachricht auf seiner Facebookseite, worin er erklärt, er hätte als Pheu Thai-Abgeordneter und nicht als Red Shirt-Führer abgestimmt.
"Out of respect for the voice of the majority, I have never opposed the opinion of the majority as a red-shirt co-leader whenever there's a resolution, even if I may personally disagree … To red-shirt brothers and sisters who are upset with me, you can criticise or curse me as much as you like and I accept it and would like to apologise for having a different opinion on the matter. But this is my frank confession."


Khattiya Sawasdipol, Pheu Thai MP, abstained from voting

Image Bangkok Post Sunday, 03 November 2013

In addition to graphic above:
If the senate rejects the bill, a bill withheld under section 147 may be reconsidered by the House of Representatives only after the lapse of one hundred and eighty days - In such cases, if the House of Representatives resolves to reaffirm the original bill or the bill considered by the joint committee by the votes of more than one-half of the total number of the existing members of the House of Representatives, such bill shall be deemed to have been approved by the National Assembly and further proceedings under section 150 shall be taken.



The amended Amnesty Bill translated by Bangkok Pundit (Siam Voices)
Tut mir leid, leider kann ich keine deutsche Übersetzung anbieten, da dieser Text bereits aus dem Thai ins Englische übersetzt wurde. Mit jeder weiteren Übersetzung würde sich das Risiko eine Fehlinterpretation des Gesetzestextes erhöhen!


Section 1: 
This Act is hereby called “Amnesty for those committed wrong acts as a result of the political protests and political expression of the people. B.E…..”
มาตรา 1 
พระราชบัญญัตินี้เรียกว่า “พระราชบัญญัตินิรโทษกรรมแก่ผู้ซึ่งกระทำความผิดเนื่องจากการชุมนุมทางการเมือง การแสดงออกทางการเมืองของประชาชน พ.ศ. ….”

Section 2: 

This Act shall be effective beginning one day after its publication in the Government Gazette มาตรา 2 
พระราชบัญญัตินี้ให้ใช้บังคับตั้งแต่วันถัดจากวันประกาศในราชกิจจานุเบกษาเป็นต้นไป

Section 3: 
All actions of persons or people that are related to political protests, political expression, political conflict, or those accused of being wrongdoers by the group of persons or entity formed after the coup of September 19, 2006 including entities or agencies who undertook [actions] as a result of what happened between 2004 until August 8, 2013 whether the person undertaking actions did so as a principal, supporter, someone who took action [on behalf of others] and someone who [ordered] others to take action, if those actions were unlawful [this Act] makes those actions to be free of wrongdoing and responsibility in full 
มาตรา 3 
ให้บรรดาการกระทำทั้งหลายทั้งสิ้นของบุคคลหรือประชาชนที่เกี่ยวเนื่องกับการชุมนุมทางการเมือง การแสดงออกทางการเมือง ความขัดแย้งทางการเมือง หรือที่ถูกกล่าวหาว่าเป็นผู้กระทำความผิดโดยคณะบุคคลหรือองค์กรที่จัดตั้งขึ้นภายหลังการรัฐประหาร เมื่อวันที่ 19 กันยายน พ.ศ.2549 รวมทั้งองค์กรหรือหน่วยงานที่ดำเนินการในเรื่องดังกล่าวสืบเนื่องต่อมาที่เกิดขึ้นระหว่าง พ.ศ.2547 ถึงวันที่ 8 สิงหาคม พ.ศ.2556 ไม่ว่าผู้กระทำจะได้กระทำในฐานะตัวการ ผู้สนับสนุน ผู้ใช้ให้กระทำ หรือผู้ถูกใช้ หากการกระทำนั้นผิดต่อกฎหมายก็ให้กระทำพ้นจากความผิดและความรับผิดโดยสิ้นเชิง

Actions in paragraph 1 do not include illegal actions under Section 112 of the Criminal Code 

การกระทำตามวรรคหนึ่ง ไม่รวมถึงการกระทำผิดตามประมวลกฎหมายอาญา มาตรา 112

Section 4: 
When this Act comes into force, if a person who has committed an act under Section 3 has not been charged before the Court or is in the process of investigation, the investigator, the person who has the person to investigate, or the prosecutor shall suspend investigation or the charging [of that person]. If the person has been charged before the Court, the prosecutor or related agencies to suspend the charging of [that person]. If that person’s case is under consideration [before the Court], whether the defendant requests or the court takes it upon themselves then the court shall issue a decision dismissing the case or disposing of the case. If in the situation where the court where there has been a final court judgment before this Act comes into force then it shall be deemed that the person has not committed a wrong 
มาตรา 4 
เมื่อพระราชบัญญัตินี้มีผลใช้บังคับแล้ว ถ้าผู้ที่กระทำการตามมาตรา 3 ยังมิได้ถูกฟ้องต่อศาลหรืออยู่ในระหว่างการสอบสวน ให้พนักงานสอบสวนผู้ซึ่งมีอำนาจสอบสวนหรือพนักงานอัยการระงับการสอบสวนหรือการฟ้องร้อง หากถูกฟ้องต่อศาลแล้วให้พนักงานอัยการหรือองค์กรที่เกี่ยวข้องระงับการฟ้อง ถ้าผู้นั้นอยู่ระหว่างการพิจารณาคดีไม่ว่าจำเลยร้องขอหรือศาลเห็นเอง ให้ศาลพิพากษายกฟ้องหรือมีคำสั่งจำหน่ายคดี ในกรณีที่ได้มีคำพิพากษาถึงที่สุดให้ลงโทษบุคคลใดก่อนวันที่พระราชบัญญัตินี้มีผลใช้บังคับ ให้ถือว่าบุคคลนั้นไม่เคยต้องคำพิพากษาว่าได้กระทำความผิด ในกรณีที่บุคคลใดอยู่ระหว่างการรับโทษ ให้ลงโทษนั้นสิ้นสุดลงและปล่อยตัวให้ผู้นั้น ทั้งนี้ ให้ทุกองค์กรหรือหน่วยงานที่เกี่ยวข้องปฏิบัติต่อกระทำการตามมาตรา 3 ให้เป็นไปตามหลักนิติธรรมตามรัฐธรรมนูญโดยเคร่งครัดต่อไป

Section 5: 
Amnesty under this Act shall not confer rights upon those who receive the Amnesty to request rights or any benefits which are related with the political protests or political expression 
มาตรา 5 
การนิรโทษกรรมตามพระราชบัญญัตินี้ ไม่ก่อให้เกิดสิทธิแก่ผู้ได้รับการนิรโทษกรรมในอันที่จะเรียกร้องสิทธิ หรือประโยชน์ใดๆ อันเกี่ยวเนื่องกับการชุมนุมทางการเมือง หรือการแสดงออกทางการเมือง

Section 6: 
Any actions taken under this Act are not the decisions of a person which is not a government organization or entity to request civil compensation from …??? [essentially, those who get amnesty aren't now eligible for government compensation, e.g. if they served a term of imprisonment, because of this law even if it caused the person damages] 
มาตรา 6 
การดำเนินการใดๆ ตามพระราชบัญญัตินี้ ไม่เป็นการตัดสินใจของบุคคลซึ่งไม่ใช่องค์กรหรือหน่วยงานของรัฐในการเรียกร้องค่าเสียหายในทางแพ่ง จากการกระทำของบุคคลใดซึ่งพ้นจากความรับผิดชอบตามพระราชบัญญัตินี้ และทำให้ตนต้องได้รับความเสียหาย

Section 7: 
The Prime Minister shall have charge and control of the execution of this Act 
มาตรา 7 
ให้นายกรัฐมนตรีรักษาการตามพระราชบัญญัตินี้

Mittwoch, 30. Oktober 2013

Die Spannungen in Bangkok steigen

Das thailändische Parlament/Repräsentantenhaus.

























To the English Version

Einige von euch erinnern sich sicherlich noch an meinen Blogeintrag vom 2.August 2013 "Thailands Gerüchteküche kocht mal wieder" (http://yanawa.blogspot.com/2013/08/thailands-geruchtekuche-kocht-mal-wieder.html). Konservative und ultra-nationalistische Oppositionsgruppen (parlamentarische und außerparlamentische) starteten in Bangkok eine Reihe von Anti-Regierungsprotesten, weil die regierende Partei Pheu Thai einen Gesetzesentwurf für eine Generalamnestie vorgelegt hatte. Die Amnestie sollte Straffreiheit für alle Lager gewähren, die an den Protesten, Unruhen und deren Niederschlagung in Mai 2010 beteiligt waren, und zwar rückwirkend bis zum Putsch vom September 2006. Im ersten Entwurf waren allerdings Thaksin Shinawatra, Abhisit Vejjajiva, Suthep Thaugsuban und die Armee von der Amnestie ausgeschlossen. Aber die Opposition befürchtete, dass der Gesetzesentwurf nachträglich zugunsten von Thaksin, der im September 2006 aus dem Amt geputscht worden war, modifiziert werden und man ihm damit die Rückkehr nach Thailand ermöglichen könnte.

Und sie lagen richtig mit ihrer Befürchtung!

Die erste Fassung der Gesetzesvorlage, eingebracht vom Pheu Thai Abgeordneten Worachai
Hema, (...sollte keine Straffreiheit für den abgesetzten Premier Thaksin Shinawatra, die Anführer der Proteste und für die für die gewaltsamen Niederschlagungen durch das Militär verantwortlichen Machthaber gewähren, für alle anderen aber, die bereits wegen politischer Straftaten und Gewalt verurteilt worden sind, sollte die Amnestie gelten... http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/local/375890/pheu-thai-presses-amnesty-bid) wurde vom Hauskomitee umgeschrieben und vom Ex-Premier Somchai Wongsawat (Mitglied der Pheu Thai und Schwager von Thaksin Shinawatra) befürwortet. Die überarbeitete Fassung schließt nun Thaksin, Abhisit, Suthep und alle verantwortlichen Autoritäten die Niederschlagungen von 2010 mit ein.

...Aber der Ausschuss stimmte der Überarbeitung des Artikels 3 der Gesetzesvorlage zu, allen Personen, die an den politischen Unruhen beteiligt waren, einschließlich der Anführer der Proteste sowie Soldaten und denjenigen Autoritäten, die die Niederschlagungen angeordnet hatten, eine Generalamnestie zu gewähren. 
Der überarbeitete Abschnitt erklärt außerdem die Entscheidungen des inzwischen aufgelösten Asset Scrutiny Committee (ASC - dem Komitee zur Vermögensüberprüfung ) für ungültig, welches nach dem Putsch 2006 die Unregelmäßigkeiten während der Regierungszeit von Thaksin Shinawatra untersucht hatte. Das gilt auch für die Ermittlungen der Anti-Korruptions-Kommission, die die Fälle vom ASC übernommen hatte...
http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/local/375890/pheu-thai-presses-amnesty-bid


Die zweite und die dritte Lesung der überarbeiteten Fassung finden vom 31.Oktober bis zum 2.November 2013 im Repräsentantenhaus statt, teilte der Parlamentssprecher Somsak Kiatsuramont am 29.Oktober mit. Die Lesungen beginnen um 10.00 Uhr morgens.


Die erweiterte Fassung des Gesetzentwurfes löste eine Welle der Empörung aus. Nicht nur die Oppositionsparteien und die außerparlamentarischen Oppositionsbewegungen sind strikt gegen besagte neue Fassung, sondern auch Koalitionspartner der Pheu Thai Party als auch einige Mitglieder der Pheu Thai selbst (in 2010 Anführer der Rothemden) sowie Angehörige und Hinterbliebene der Opfer der Niederschlagungen. Die Unterstützer der "Anti-112"-Bewegung (z.B. das 112 Family Network) lehnen das Gesetz ebenfalls ab, weil politische Gefangene bzw. wegen Majestätsbeleidigung Verurteilte von der Amnestie ausgeschlossen sind.

Aber warum fürchtet sich die Opposition so sehr vor der Rückkehr Thaksins? 
Wegen der Generalamnestie wäre Thaksin nicht länger aus der Politik verbannt und könnte sofort in die Politik zurückkehren (was sehr wahrscheinlich ist). Seine Schwester bräuchte dann nur noch das Parlament aufzulösen und vorgezogene Neuwahlen auszurufen, und es ist zur Zeit keine Frage, wer die Wahl gewinnen und der nächste Premierminister von Thailand wäre. Thaksin wurde durch einen Putsch aus dem Amt gejagt und lebte für nahezu fünf Jahre im Exil (seit dem Gerichtsurteil 2008). Er wurde öffentlich gedemütigt. Und wenn es etwas gibt, was ein Thai weder vergibt noch vergisst, dann ist es eine öffentliche Demütigung. Ein Grund wäre daher, dass die Führer der Opposition nach einer möglichen Rückkehr Thaksins in die Politik sich vor einen möglichen Rachefeldzug fürchten. Es gibt noch weitere mögliche Gründe, auf die ich hier leider nicht eingehen kann, da ich in Thailand lebe und hier es per Gesetz verboten ist, öffentlich darüber zu reden oder zu schreiben.

Armeechef General Prayuth Chan-ocha erklärte, das Militär brauche keine Amnestie, da die Soldaten nur Befehle ausgeführt hätten und die Königlich-Thailändische Armee keine der am Konflikt beteiligten Parteien gewesen sei.
http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/security/376878/prayuth-army-does-not-want-amnesty

Die oppositionelle Democrat Party ist ebenfalls gegen den Gesetzesentwurf und erklärte, dass sie alles unternehmen werde, um die Abstimmung über das Gesetz so lange wie möglich hinauszuzögern. Ihr Ziel ist es, den Anti-Regierungsbewegungen genügend Zeit zu geben, um Massenproteste zu organisieren.  Außerdem wollen sie sich den Straßenprotesten anschließen.

Am 7.August 2013 folgten nur ca. 2.500 Demonstranten dem Protestaufruf der Democrat Party.
























Mehrere außerparlamentarische Oppositionsgruppen haben sich am Sonntag, den 27.Oktober zusammengeschlossen. Sie nennen sich jetzt PART (People's Assembley Reforming Thailand - Volksversammlung für die Reformierung Thailands). Die neue Gruppierung setzt sich zusammen aus ehemaligen Mitgliedern und Anführern der inzwischen aufgelösten PAD (People's Alliance for Democracy), Mitstreitern der Pitak Siam-Bewegung (ebenfalls aufgelöst), der PEFOT-Bewegung (People's Force for Democracy to Overthrow Thaksinism), welche ein permanentes Camp im Lumpini Park eingerichtet hat, und dem Studenten- und Volksnetzwerk für Thailand (zusammen mit den White Masks), die seit Wochen an der Urupong-Straßenkreuzung demonstrieren.

Die PEFOT-Bühne im Lumpini Park




Bilder mit Anti-Thaksin bzw. Anti-Regierungspropaganda.




White Mask-Demonstranten




































































Interessanterweise aber protestieren auch mehrere Gruppierungen der Rothemden gegen das geplante Amnestiegesetz. Darunter Sombat Boon-ngam-anongs Red Sunday Bewegung, Anhänger von Surachai Danwattananusorn sowie Unterstützer der Free Somyot Bewegung. Sombat erklärte am 29.Oktober, dass er sich mit mehreren Vertretern anderer Red Shirt-Gruppierungen getroffen und man vereinbart habe, am Sonntag, den 10. November einen Massenprotest gegen das neue Gesetz zu organisieren.
...Sombat räumte ein, dass die Aktivisten nicht viel Zeit hätten, die Menschen gegen die Generalamnestie zu mobilisieren, wenn das Repräsentantenhaus die dritte Lesung des Gesetzentwurfes bereits am Samstag halte. Dennoch sei er überzeugt, dass mehr als 10.000 Menschen dem Protestaufruf folgen würden...
(http://www.bangkokpost.com/breakingnews/377037/red-shirts-vow-to-rally-against-blanket-amnesty-bill)

Natürlich wären die meisten Rothemden über eine baldige Rückkehr Thaksins nach Thailand  hocherfreut, ALLERDINGS nicht um jeden Preis. Während des Protestes an der Ratchaprasong-Kreuzung am letzten Sonntag, den 27.Oktober, erklärten uns mehrere Demonstranten, dass diejenigen, die für die Gewalt und die Toten und Verletzten während der Proteste in 2009 und 2010 verantwortlich seien, auch zur Verantwortung gezogen werden müssten (was in Thailands Geschichte bisher noch nie passiert ist). Sie sollten nicht ungeschoren davonkommen, wie schon so häufig zuvor. Würden die Verantwortlichen wieder mal ohne Bestrafung davon kommen, so wäre das ein Freibrief für weitere Gewalt, Niederschlagungen und Militärputsche in der Zukunft.


Ca. 250 - 350 Rothemden protestierten am 27.Oktober gegen das Amnestiegesetz an der Ratchaprasong-Kreuzung.



Protest der Red Sunday Bewegung gegen den Gesetzesentwurf am 27.Oktober 2013.















































Der Artikel AMNESTIE FÜR ALLE: WAS WERDEN UNSERE KINDER SAGEN von Anuthee Dejthevaporn (Prachatai: http://www.prachatai3.info/english/node/3720) bringt das Problem auf den Punkt:
...If the ‘Amnesty for All’ bill is passed, then consider the consequences that may come. What will our children say, if one day they also get killed in a future political conflict and they have to fight for the justice all over again by themselves? What will our children say, when they realize that we, their parents, could have done some big things to create the true justice in this land for them, but sadly we didn’t?...

Die nächsten Tage und Wochen könnten sehr spannend werden. Wird die Anti-Thaksin und Anti-Regierungsbewegung in der Lage sein, innerhalb kürzester Zeit genügend Unterstützer zu mobilisieren, um neue Massenproteste zu organisieren? Wird es eventuell zu neuen gewaltsamen Zwischenfällen kommen? Oder ist es wieder mal der berühmt-berüchtigte Sturm im Wasserglas? Meiner Meinung nach ist das Momentum der Opposition noch nicht groß genug, um Zehntausende auf die Straßen zu bringen. Und zehn- bis zwanzigtausend Demonstranten reichen bei weitem nicht aus, die Regierung zu stürzen oder die Verabschiedung des Gesetzes zu verhindern.


Tensions are rising again in Thailand

The parliament building.

























Zur Deutschen Version

To the updated Version of November 1st
http://yanawa.blogspot.com/2013/11/the-blanket-amnesty-bill-final-version.html

Some of you may remember my piece about Bangkoks "relaunched political gossip-factory" I wrote a couple of months ago (2nd August 2013: http://yanawa.blogspot.com/2013/08/thailands-gossip-factory-is-working.html). Right wing and conservative opposition groups (parlamentarian and non-parlamentarian) started a new series of anti-government protests in Bangkok in early August, because the ruling party Pheu Thai introduced a proposal for an amnesty bill in parliament, which should grant impunity for all people involved in political protests and unrest since the coup d'etat 2006, excluding Thaksin Shinawatra, Abhisit Vejjajiva, Suthep Thaugsuban and the military. But the opposition feared that the proposed bill would be modified to grant amnesty for ousted (and self-exiled) former Premier Thaksin Shinawatra and allow him to return to Thailand.

And they were right!

The first version of the amnesty bill, proposed by Pheu Thai Party MP Worachai Hema (...would not have granted an amnesty to ousted premier Thaksin Shinawatra, the protest leaders and the authorities responsible for the military crackdowns, but would have included everyone else convicted of crimes relating to political violence...  http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/local/375890/pheu-thai-presses-amnesty-bid), had been modified and rewritten by the House commitee and recommended by former PM Somchai Wongsawat (Pheu Thai Party and brother-in-law of Thaksin Shinawatra). The new version of the bill now includes Thaksin, Abhisit, Suthep and all responsible authorities for the crackdown in 2010.
...But the panel voted to approve revisions to Section 3 of the bill to grant a blanket amnesty to all people involved in political unrest, including protest leaders, soldiers, and authorities responsible for ordering the crackdowns. 
The amended section would also invalidate the decisions of the now-defunct Asset Scrutiny Committee (ASC) which investigated alleged irregularities of the Thaksin Shinawatra administration after the 2006 coup, as well as those by the National Anti-Corruption Commission, which took over the ASC's cases...


The second and third reading of the altered amnesty bill will be held from 31 October 2013 until 2 November 2013 at the House of Representatives, House Speaker Somsak Kiatsuranont announced on 29 October 2013. The sessions will start at 10.00 AM.


This altered version of the amnesty bill triggered an enormous wave of anger. Not only the opposition parties and non-parliamentarian anti-government groups are enraged but also coalition partners of the ruling Pheu Thai Party, and some members of Pheu Thai party itself (who had been red shirt leaders in 2010) as well as relatives of the killed and injured victims of the crackdowns are speaking out against the modified version. The "Anti 112" movement (e.g. the 112 family network) is also opposing the amnesty bill because lèse majesté/political prisoners are excluded from the amnesty.

But why is the opposition so afraid of Thaksin´s return to Thailand? 
Because of the blanket amnesty he would no longer be banned from politics and could and will re-enter the political arena again (what is very likely)! His sister Yingluck could dissolve the parliament and call for early elections and there is no question who will be the next Prime Minister of Thailand. He was kicked out of office by the September 2006 military coup and had to flee the country (self imposed exile since 2008). One reason maybe that he has been publicly humiliated. Especially humiliation ist something a Thai will neither forget nor forgive and therefor his opponents possibly fear his revenge. Certainly there might be other reasons, but living in Thailand  I am not allowed to write about those topics, otherwise I would end up in prison!

Army chief Prayuth Chan-ocha declared that the army does not need an amnesty because the soldiers only followed orders and the Royal Thai Army was not one of the conflicting parties.
http://www.bangkokpost.com/news/security/376878/prayuth-army-does-not-want-amnesty

The Democrat Party also opposes the amnesty bill and already declared that its members will do whatever they can to prolong the second and third reading as long as possible. Their intention is to give the anti-government movements enough time to organize mass rallies. Finally, they will join the street movements in their protest against the new law.

On  August 7th only around 2,500 protesters joined the protest organized by the Democrat Party.

Other non-parlamentarian groups already teamed up and vowed to fight the bill by all means. They call themselves now PART ( People's Assembly Reforming Thailand). PART consists of former supporters and core leaders of the disbanded PAD (People's Alliance for Democracy), followers of the Pitak Siam movement (also disbanded), the PEFOT (People's Force for Democracy to Overthrow Thaksinism) which put up a permanent protest camp at Lumpini park, and the Students´ and People´s Network for Thailand Reform (joined by the White Mask movement) that has established a protest site at Urupong Intersection.

PEFOT stage at Lumpini Park.


Anti-Thaksin and anti-government propaganda.

White Mask protesters.

But also several red shirt groups and red shirt supporters such as Sombat Boon-ngam-anong's Red Sunday movement, followers of Surachai Danwattananusorn or supporters of the Free Somyot movement expressed their disappointment and their anger. Sombat declared on 29 October that he met with several leaders of other red shirt groups and that they agreed to organize a mass rally against the amnesty bill on Sunday, 10 November 2013.
...Mr Sombat admitted activists may not have enough time to mobilise people against the blanket amnesty if the House votes on the bill's third reading on Saturday. However, he said he still expected the anti-amnesty gathering next Sunday to draw more than 10,000 people...
(http://www.bangkokpost.com/breakingnews/377037/red-shirts-vow-to-rally-against-blanket-amnesty-bill)

Most of the red shirts, of course, would be happy about Thaksin's return to Thailand, however, not at any price! Several red shirt protesters on last Sunday's protest (27 October) at Ratchaprasong intersection told us that those who were responsible for the violence and the killings during the protests in 2009 and 2010 should be held accountable (which would be the first time ever in Thailand's history) and that they should not be given a pardon as it had happened so many times in the past. If those responsible escape unpunished again, this amnesty bill would be a carte blanche for new violence, crackdowns and military coup d'etats in the future .

Around 250-350 red shirts protested on 27 October 2013 against the amnesty bill at Ratchaprasong .




Protest against the amnesty bill by the Red Sunday movement on Sunday, 27 October 2013.

The article AMNESTY FOR ALL: WHAT WILL OUR CHILDREN SAY by Anuthee Dejthevaporn (Prachatai: http://www.prachatai3.info/english/node/3720) got to the heart of the problem.
...If the ‘Amnesty for All’ bill is passed, then consider the consequences that may come. What will our children say, if one day they also get killed in a future political conflict and they have to fight for the justice all over again by themselves? What will our children say, when they realize that we, their parents, could have done some big things to create the true justice in this land for them, but sadly we didn’t?...

The next days and weeks could be very interesting indeed! Will the anti-Thaksin and anti-government movements be able to mobilise enough supporters to organise new mass protests? Will we witness violent incidents again, or is this just another storm in a tea cup? In my opinion the momentum is NOT strong enough for the opposition to mobilise tens of thousands of protesters yet. Ten or twenty thousand people certainly won't be enough to bring down the government or to stop the passage oft the amnesty bill.